Creamy Coleslaw Dressing Recipe – Southern & Homemade
This post may contain affiliate links. Please check our privacy and disclosure policy.
This Creamy Coleslaw Dressing Recipe is the classic southern style that you can easily make with ingredients you already have in your kitchen. It’s sweet, creamy, tangy and crunchy, just like a good southern coleslaw should be.
Coleslaw Dressing Recipe
Happy Monday, and welcome April! Let’s start this month off right with a little bit of creamy, a little bit of crunchy, and a whole lot of comfort. This Coleslaw Dressing Recipe is the sweet and tangy start we all need this month. I’m getting ready for spring time which means plenty of BBQ and family gatherings. And while I’m gearing up the grilling recipes, we’re always going to need some side dishes to go along with it. And that’s where this super quick and easy slaw recipe comes in handy!
Southern Coleslaw Dressing
I hope everyone had a great holiday. I spent the day with family, just cooking and enjoying the beautiful weather down here in Florida. Right now it’s in the mid 80’s, which is perfect weather to take the dogs to the park and break out the grill. In fact, I have a series of grilling recipes for the spring and summer coming up over the next few weeks, so don’t miss it! For now, check out these smoked ribs, to hold you over. And yes, you can make them on a gas grill!
But for today, I want to share with you something that often gets overlooked, but deserves its own chance to shine. My southern coleslaw recipe.
What Makes A Southern Coleslaw Recipe Different?
That’s a little bit of a tricky question to answer, because everyone has a different idea of what a southern coleslaw recipe is. The short answer involves two important factors.
1.) Southern Coleslaw has an incredibly creamy, sweet, and tangy texture.
- This is usually from mayonnaise or buttermilk (or both).
- Plus a vinegar or acid taste, to balance out the sweetness.
- Sugar is involved in this glorious blend. And if you get the blend right, it won’t be an overpowering sweetness, either.
2.) Southern Coleslaw is comfort food.
- Do you feel comforted after you eat it, or can you pair it with your favorite comfort foods like Smoked BBQ Ribs?
- It’s really easy and simple to make, but it still tastes like it was made with a whole lotta’ love, ya’ll.
How to Make Coleslaw Dressing
If you’ve been wondering how to make coleslaw dressing, look no further. I’m here to tell you how incredibly easy this is to do. All you need is a whisk, a few ingredients, a bowl, and a pocket full of dream. But first, we should discuss the three typical coleslaw ingredients you’re going to come across.
- Sour Cream
Classic Coleslaw Dressing Uses Mayonnaise.
There’s no way around this one if you want to achieve that creamy, crunchy texture of a good comforting coleslaw recipe. You’ll find a lot of different variations or blends if you do a quick internet search. In my opinion, none of them come close to the mayo version. This is how restaurants make it so irresistible! But I’m trying to keep it a little bit healthy here, so I’m using light mayonnaise in my version.
Let’s Not Forget About Buttermilk!
I admit it, as a transplant southerner, buttermilk is like currency in the potluck community. You’ll find it sneaking into all kinds of recipes, including coleslaw. It adds another layer of flavor to the creamy texture, but it also adds another layer of fat. Great for holidays, or a get-together. But if I’m making this for my family, I’ll probably leave this one out.
Last But Not Least, Sour Cream.
If I’m in a pinch, I might use some light sour cream instead of (or in addition to) mayonnaise. This also adds another layer of flavor to the dressing, so you have to like how sour cream tastes to really enjoy this version of the salad.
What Else Can We Add to Homemade Coleslaw Dressing?
After the three main ingredients, you’re looking at what type of flavor profile you want to achieve in your homemade coleslaw dressing. You have a few options here.
- Vinegar – This will add a good brightness and tang to your dressing, but you want to be careful about how much you add. A little bit goes a long way! Try to keep it to around 3-4 tablespoons, max. Vinegar will also balance out the sweetness of the dressing overall.
- Seasoning – A lot of times you’ll find the usual salt and pepper. But here you can really think outside the box! Try celery seed, poppy seeds, garlic, or even a little Dijon mustard. Experiment until you get the flavor you want.
- Sugar – It’s not enough to make your salad taste like candy, but it’s more like a balance between the sweet and the savory here. If you’re finding your homemade coleslaw too sweet, you can cut back on the sugar and go up on the vinegar just a touch. Everyone has different tastes here, so find a balance that works for you.
- Cabbage – Last but not least, the cabbage. I am partial to green, but I have a confession to make here. I buy the pre-cut version. That’s right! I want my homemade coleslaw to be quick and easy. I whisk up a few ingredients, and throw it on top of the pre-cut bag of cabbage. But you can cut up a blend of different cabbage varieties if you want, or even try it out with broccoli-slaw!
Creamy Coleslaw Dressing Recipe - Southern & Homemade
- 1 cup light mayonnaise
- 1/2 cup white sugar
- 3 tbsp apple cider vinegar
- 1/2 tsp onion powder
- 1/4 tsp celery salt
- 1/4 tsp poppy seeds
- 1 16oz bag shredded cabbage
- In a medium bowl whisk together mayo, vinegar, and sugar. Whisk in spices and poppy seeds until everything is well combined.
- To make coleslaw, add this to a 16oz bag of pre-cut cabbage or coleslaw mix.
We are a participant in both the RewardStyle and Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, which are affiliate advertising programs designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com and through RewardStyle.
Oh my goodness, my mouth is watering! This looks and sounds delicious. I am so going to try this with vegan mayonnaise 🙂
I just yesterday made this coleslaw dressing…..absolutely delish 🥂
Oh my goodness, I can easily make this vegan by substituting vegan mayo and otherwise, all the other ingredients are awesome. Coleslaw Southern style: my fav!
Oh my, I don’t eat mayonnaise but I can easily substitute vegan mayo for regular mayo. Right on, I’m all over it!
What a delicious Creamy Coleslaw Dressing Recipe! I simply cannot wait to try it! Very interesting combination of ingredients. I am saving this recipe for later.
Just in time for grilling season! My husband loves this recipe.
That’s great! Grilling season is upon us!
Besides eating this straight up I could think of so many uses for this, particularly piled high on a sandwich! Yum!
Great idea! I originally made this because we had pulled pork for dinner, it was really good!
I love using buttermilk in recipes! This sounds delicious 🙂
Thanks! Buttermilk is definitely an option, depending what version you make 🙂
I love coleslaw and haven’t had it in a while. i really wanna make this and was wondering if i could use honey instead as I stay away from sugar.
Hi Andrea, I haven’t tried this with honey, but I think it could be really interesting! I would definitely cut back on the amount, maybe try 1/4 cup and see how it is, then add to taste.
I’ve never made coleslaw before nor the dressing for it. But I will. Because I have cabbage at home and broccoli. Thanks for the recipe.
ahhh – I LOVE poppyseed dressing! making a coleslaw with it is such a great idea – cannot wait to do this!
This looks so good. I can’t wait to try it!
It may not be traditional, but I like adding the liquid from dill pickles instead of plain vinegar. No self respecting southerner would have a BBQ without coleslaw on the menu.
Oh dill pickles, that’s a great idea! I’m going to try it!
Oh this looks mouthwatering! I can’t wait to have this at our next BBQ!
This is a true-to-the-south coleslaw dressing. Love it! Here in the south, coleslaw is part of any gathering.
Fresh coleslaw is always a welcome salad. I like to add pineapple and poppyseed to mine.
I can’t wait for the weather to be warm enough up here for outside BBQs. This looks delicious! I love how creamy it is, and the addition of the dill pickles is unique and tasty!
Thanks! I’ll have to try the dill pickle tip 🙂
This is one of my favorite classic recipes. And I just love coleslaw on burgers and sandwiches!
I love this dressing. I made it last night with a half a bag of slaw. Using the other half tonight because I enjoyed it so much.. Thank you for a wonderful recipe.
This is the best coleslaw dressing I have ever made. My husband loves it so I make it a lot. I do reduce the sugar but otherwise it’s perfect for us.
Best coleslaw recipe I have ever tried!
My husband loved it and he’s hard to impress! Thank you for sharing 😊
Thank you so much for sharing your cole slaw recipe. I have been trying all different recipes and finally found the one! I followed it exactly and loved it. This time I substituted 1/3 cup of honey for the sugar because I’m a bee keeper and it turned out just as good. Thanks for sharing.
Honey sounds awesome, I’m going to try that!!
So simple and delicious. I added addition too, 2 Tbl spoons Plain Greek yogurt, and 2 Tbl spoons lemon juice, and instead of 1/2 c of sugar I only used 1/4 because we don’t want it as sweet. Thank you for all the ways to make it Perfect for my family